I first showed 1421 Reynolds to buyers in 2014. Then I made an offer myself. Follow the renovation—from the original rooms and open framing to the home where we raised our family.
$1.05MMedian sale priceExact figure: $1,046,250Down 7.8% · previously $1,135,000
257Active homesUp 12.2% · previously 229
Citywide Key West residential MLS snapshots. Sales: July 30–October 30, 2026 (through the October 30, 9 a.m. ET capture), versus April 30–July 29, 2026; preceding-period records saved October 19. Active inventory: October 30 versus September 30, both at 9 a.m. ET. Median price changes can reflect the mix of homes sold.
