Old Town
Old Town is Key West's historic core — narrow lanes lined with 19th-century Conch houses, gingerbread trim, and mature tropical landscaping, all within walking distance of Duval Street and Mallory Square.
It's the most tourist-facing part of the island and one of the most residential at the same time: short-term rental and transient-licensed properties sit block-to-block with quiet family homes. Buyers come here for walkability, architectural character, and the ability to be part of the island's daily rhythm rather than removed from it.
69
Active listings
$1.89M
Median asking price
161 days
Average days on market · Active
DOM recorded for all 69 matching listings.
Market Pulse · All residential inventory · Updated Oct 11, 2026, 9:00 PM ET. Refreshed twice daily.
View Market Pulse →Homes for Sale in Old Town
Listings below are IDX search results. IDX refresh timing and search definitions may differ from the Market Pulse snapshot above. Condo and Waterfront filters apply only to these IDX results; the market summary covers all residential inventory.
Get Old Town Listing Alerts
Be the first to know when a new home hits the market in Old Town — no spam, unsubscribe any time.