Shark Key
Shark Key is a small, gated island a short drive from Key West proper, developed exclusively with large waterfront estates set among protected mangrove channels. Access is restricted to residents and their guests.
It draws buyers who want serious acreage and deep water access without being on the main island at all — a different trade than Sunset Key's walk-to-everything seclusion, closer in spirit to a private compound.
2
Active listings
$9.35M
Median asking price
123 days
Average days on market · Active
DOM recorded for all 2 matching listings.
Market Pulse · All residential inventory · Updated Oct 11, 2026, 9:00 PM ET. Refreshed twice daily.
View Market Pulse →Homes for Sale in Shark Key
Listings below are IDX search results. IDX refresh timing and search definitions may differ from the Market Pulse snapshot above. Condo and Waterfront filters apply only to these IDX results; the market summary covers all residential inventory.
Get Shark Key Listing Alerts
Be the first to know when a new home hits the market in Shark Key — no spam, unsubscribe any time.