Sunset Key
Sunset Key is a private island a short ferry ride from Key West Bight, developed exclusively with luxury homes and a resort-operated cottage collection. There are no cars, no through traffic, and no public access — privacy is effectively the product.
It's the most exclusive address in the Key West market, drawing buyers who want island living with a level of seclusion the main island simply can't offer.
1
Active listings
$12.5M
Median asking price
72 days
Average days on market · Active
DOM recorded for all 1 matching listings.
Market Pulse · All residential inventory · Updated Oct 11, 2026, 9:00 PM ET. Refreshed twice daily.
View Market Pulse →Homes for Sale in Sunset Key
Listings below are IDX search results. IDX refresh timing and search definitions may differ from the Market Pulse snapshot above. Condo and Waterfront filters apply only to these IDX results; the market summary covers all residential inventory.
Get Sunset Key Listing Alerts
Be the first to know when a new home hits the market in Sunset Key — no spam, unsubscribe any time.